I was trying to find a household cleaning product that was marketed using men, or at least using both men and women equally. Overall, I found that task pretty difficult. The majority of the websites that I found used a motherly figure to sell the product, or an image of a part of a woman cleaning (ie a delicately manicured hand ). Then I came across Mr. Clean's website which features a section on Mr. Clean through the years. This image was featured in advertisements in 1957. I thought that it was quite interesting. It does not portray the stereotypical man (especially for the 1950s) as a person who partakes in household cleaning, but rather a man being comically placed into a 'woman's role' to make a point.
I find it mostly frustrating that all of the commercials that we see on TV that deal with cleaning in the home feature a woman, usually a mother, and a wife in a heterosexual relationship (when relationships are featured) doing the cleaning. As if the only concerns that she has is how to make her whites whiter and her brights brighter, or how to get rid of the most dust with the least amount of effort. I do remember a swiffer commercial from a while ago that showed a man doing the cleaning...however, the message that was being passed on was along the lines of 'so easy to use a man could do it'. I think that this type of message is equally as problematic. It is offensive to men. To sell cleaning products we don't need to make one gender look stupid.
Also, as we talked about in class...the new angle that swiffer is using to sell their products. Here is a little sample of what they are doing. They are making the women in the commercials look like they are having a love affair with their new cleaning tools. Really, swiffer? Sexualizing inanimate objects now?
***Looie***
Whoever thought up this whole housewife/cleaning product romance must of been so WEIRD! LOL, I mean really...REALLY! It just plays up on the idea of the stereotypical bored, unstimulated, ignored housewife, but wow, things would have to be pretty bad if you started fantasizing about Mr.Clean!! I love how in the past the sexualizing of these products was much more discreet and allowed the viewer to decide on their own whether or not the housewife in the commercials was really lusting over the man on the cleaning-product label or if it just appeared that way, and now Sniffer just puts it completely out there...lol!
ReplyDeleteI found this vintage "Brawny" commercial that goes along with what I just said :) lol.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=92KpxGWXIGk&NR=1
*Silver
This one too!!! LOL!
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DSueysZfrFE&feature=related
*Silver
These commercials are frustrating to me for a variety of reasons. Firstly, they offer the viewer the idea that the ultimate romance for a woman is not in fact with another human being (whether male or female) but with utilitarian objects with which one cleans their home-- once again enforcing the idea that to be truly happy one must have a clean and tidy home. "Angel in the House" much?
ReplyDeleteSeveral of us in 2113 take Helen Smith's 2335 class directly after, and it focuses on women in pre-confederate Canada, now while they obviously did not have television commercials, there are several examples (one for steel wool) that imply the road to true happiness is through cleaning your home.
Okay, seriously? I am pretty sure that I do not need to dance with a swiffer on a daily basis to be romantically happy in my life, or happy at all for that matter. You're just pushing the dirt around for gosh sake!
I digress, I feel this particular commercial targets women rather specifically, playing on gendered insecurities that have been there for centuries. Will he love you if your house is dirty? Will he love you if there are crumbs on the floor? No? Better get a swiffer... because with that old broom, there's no way you're going to land yourself a man.
I exit this post with one defeated "ugh" because this commercial is awful, and I feel defeated because I am not even remotely surprised.
*who
As brutal as these commercials are, I find them pretty funny. Watch this swiffer ad...http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SRPeYhW_qG4&feature=related. Your right *who about woman's romantic relationships being based on objects rather than people, that's unfortunate. Its easy to see that these ads perpetuate nothing but stereotypical ideas of a woman's role in the home and in love.
ReplyDeleteThe ads and commercials are so full of stupidity and it works... they sell! They are so cliche and insinuate that cleaning products are what a woman wants and needs!:) Its funny.
Danger Powers
Cleaning products marketed towards women can be a complicated topic, because on the one hand seeing ads for cleaning products that make cleaning easier it deems maintaining your home a difficult and necessary task, thus implying that women's work in the home has credibility alongside a payed job. While also suggesting that it is a woman's duty (in order to maintain a happy marriage amongst other things) to keep the house spotless. I'm sure there are way more complications than that, but I couldn't ignore a thought I had about these ads validating domestic work.
ReplyDeleteGesundheit.
I completely agree with you Looie. The fact that cleaning products are mostly geared towards women whilst making men look inadequate of any type of cleaning is absurd. I have never thought about how commercials have been sexualizing newer cleaning products (Swiffer) lately. This ultimately creates a notion that the woman depicted could be a lonesome housewife (i.e. "love stinks" from the commercial). This is replacing any type of spouse with a mop, the initial love interest of a "housewife". I completely see it all as extremely problematic, because today if you actually go into a heterosexual couple's home, I am positive that you will find the couple equally sharing household duties and taking turns. These commercials are trying to keep an oppressive stereotype over women, where they are seen as deemed solely for housecleaning and they are just selling us laziness. It is amazing to see the old advertisement from the 1950's and to see exactly how far we have come, which is not that far.
ReplyDeleteVery interesting to discuss!
Aaliyah Jasmine